Call us1300 66 88 14Tap to call ›

Payroll Reconciliation in Australia: What NAB’s $127 Million Back-Payment Means for Small Business

Cafe owner and barista checking staff hours on a tablet behind the counter of an Australian cafe

Last updated: 17 November 2026. Written by the FreeMyCloud team.

Checked against the Fair Work Ombudsman’s media release, record-keeping, annualised wages, pay slips, enforceable undertakings and underpayment pages, and the ATO super guarantee page, on 17 November 2026.

Payroll reconciliation: the short answers (as at 17 November 2026)

  • Payroll reconciliation compares what each employee was paid against what the award required for the hours worked.
  • National Australia Bank is paying $127 million in wages, $34 million interest and $8 million superannuation to 65,999 workers under an enforceable undertaking signed 12 November 2026.
  • The regulator named inadequate record-keeping, legacy payroll technology and missed reconciliation checks among the causes.
  • Time and wages records must be kept 7 years and be accessible to a Fair Work Inspector.
  • An annualised wage under an award usually must be reviewed every 12 months, and any shortfall paid.

Payroll reconciliation is the check that compares what you actually paid each employee against what the award, enterprise agreement or contract required for the hours they actually worked. It is the step skipped when payroll runs on time and nobody complains. On 12 November 2026 the Fair Work Ombudsman published an enforceable undertaking showing where that leads: National Australia Bank is paying $127 million in wages to 65,999 workers. This article covers what the regulator found and what payroll reconciliation involves in a much smaller business.

What happened at NAB, and what did the Fair Work Ombudsman say?

The Fair Work Ombudsman said on 12 November 2026 that National Australia Bank had entered an enforceable undertaking after underpaying workers in every state and territory over more than a decade. The bank self-reported in late 2019 after finding errors in how it implemented its enterprise agreement. The review traced problems back to 2012, and a new agreement in 2024 revealed they had not been adequately fixed.

The regulator was specific about the causes: governance deficiencies, compliance oversights, inadequate record-keeping, legacy payroll technology, and limited investment in specialist payroll capability. In practical terms it said NAB had failed to run the regular reconciliation checks its own agreement required, comparing wages paid against what employees would have received under the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2010. It also said the bank had not adequately captured time and attendance data.

What the Fair Work Ombudsman reported Figure
Wages being back-paid $127 million
Interest, and superannuation $34 million, and $8 million
Workers affected 65,999
Range of individual back-payments Less than $5 to more than $87,000
Average back-payment About $1,934

Fair Work Ombudsman Anna Booth said the case highlighted “the serious, long-running problems that can arise when an employer fails to coordinate key business functions to meet their workplace obligations”. She said the regulator welcomed NAB’s efforts across many years to find and rectify the underpayments.

What does a $127 million underpayment mean for a small business?

Retail shop manager and a staff member going through a stack of paper timesheets at a back of house desk
Reconciliation starts with the hours, not the payslip.

Nothing about a bank with 65,999 affected workers maps onto a cafe with six casuals. The figures are not the lesson; the mechanism is. Pay was set once, the entitlement moved, and nothing compared the two again for years.

A small business has fewer employees but often fewer defences: no internal audit function, and nobody whose job is to read the award when it changes. Payroll is usually run by the owner between other work, which is exactly where an annual wage review, a classification change or a drift in rostered hours goes unnoticed, and where payroll compliance problems compound instead of surfacing.

What is payroll reconciliation, and what does it actually check?

Payroll reconciliation compares two sets of numbers: what the business paid, and what it owed. Payroll software reports the first accurately. It cannot tell you the second unless the award interpretation, classifications, allowances and hours loaded into it are correct and current.

The two sides of the check

What was paid comes from the payroll system. What was owed comes from the award, applied to the hours actually worked. A reconciliation that only reads the payroll system is checking its own homework.

What time and attendance records do you need?

The Fair Work Ombudsman’s record-keeping page sets out what must be kept, and the hours category is the one most often thin. Employers have to record overtime hours with their start and finish times, and the hours worked by any casual or irregular part-time employee paid on time worked. Recording hours for everyone is treated as best practice, because without hours there is nothing to reconcile against. NAB’s time and attendance data was one of the gaps the regulator named.

Which employee entitlements get missed most often?

At NAB the employee entitlements underpaid included minimum wages, penalty rates, shift loadings, overtime, allowances, termination payments, leave and superannuation. Smaller businesses repeat the same categories: allowances that sit in the award and never reach the pay run, annual leave loading applied to the wrong people, and penalty rates on hours rostered differently from how they were worked. Venues feel it hardest, which is why hospitality payroll carries so much of it.

What is an annualised salary, and why does it need reconciling every year?

Two FreeMyCloud graduate accountants in navy freemycloud polo shirts reviewing a printed payroll report at a desk in the Manila office
Routine work that benefits from being someone’s job.

An annualised salary is where small businesses most closely resemble the NAB facts. The Fair Work Ombudsman’s annualised wages and salaries page explains that some awards let an employer pay a fixed amount each pay period over a year instead of an hourly wage for each hour worked.

The critical rule is the comparison. Generally an annualised wage must not be less than what the employee would have received under the award for the work performed during the year. Awards usually require a review every 12 months, or sooner if the arrangement or employment ends. The regulator also says to check when award rates change and when an employee’s classification or hours change significantly. If the total fell short, the difference must be paid.

Annualised salaries carry extra records

Where an employee is paid an annual wage under an award, the Fair Work Ombudsman says employers are required to keep extra records for that employee on top of the standard time and wages records.

What does a payroll audit look at, and what records does it need?

A payroll audit depends on records, which is why the regulator named record-keeping as a cause at NAB. Time and wages records must be kept for 7 years, be accessible to a Fair Work Inspector and legible in English, and cannot be changed except to correct an error. Pay slips are separate: the pay slips page says they must be given within 1 working day of pay day, even if the employee is on leave.

Record What it has to show Keep for
General and pay Names, ABN, start date, employment type, pay rate, gross and net, deductions, allowances 7 years
Hours of work Overtime hours with start and finish times, casual hours worked 7 years
Leave Leave taken and balances, plus any cash-out agreement 7 years
Superannuation Amount, pay period, dates paid, fund name 7 years

The ATO’s guidance on how much super to pay states the rate is 12% of ordinary time earnings for payments made from 1 July 2025, that super must be paid at least four times a year, and that missing a quarterly due date means the super guarantee charge applies instead. The same logic runs through payday super and Single Touch Payroll.

How do you work out back pay if a shortfall shows up?

Trades business owner in a high visibility shirt and an office administrator reviewing payroll on a monitor in a workshop office
Shortfalls show up by comparing two columns.

The Fair Work Ombudsman sets out a sequence for employers who think they have underpaid someone. First, establish which award or agreement applies and what it requires. Second, check what was actually paid, using past pay slips, records and payroll reports. Back pay is the difference across the underpayment period.

The regulator then expects the employer to talk to the employee, explain what happened and share the calculations. Where the amount is more than the business can pay at once, it says to discuss an arrangement. It also points small businesses to its free Employer Advisory Service.

A back pay bill is driven mostly by how long an error ran, not how large it was each week: NAB’s average back-payment was about $1,934, and the total reached $127 million only because the error ran for more than a decade. Contractor versus employee matters here too, because people wrongly treated as contractors never appear in a payroll reconciliation at all.

Can outsourced payroll keep payroll reconciliation on schedule?

It can, with a clear limit. Outsourced payroll moves the processing and the checking to someone whose job it is, on a set cycle, with the reconciliation documented rather than remembered. FreeMyCloud has placed university-qualified graduate accountants based in the Philippines with Australian businesses since 2010, working Australian business hours and able to work with Xero, MYOB, QuickBooks, Reckon or the client’s software, at about 50% less than employing a bookkeeper locally. The savings calculator estimates the difference.

The limit: FreeMyCloud is not a registered tax or BAS agent and does not lodge. Interpreting an ambiguous award clause, or deciding how to handle a historical underpayment, is work for a workplace relations professional, and the Fair Work Infoline on 13 13 94 is free. What an outsourced payroll team does is the part that fails through neglect rather than difficulty: running the cycle, keeping records complete, doing the comparison on time. The same holds for the wider bookkeeping and accounting work and for small business bookkeeping; what a bookkeeper does sets out the split with your accountant.

Outsourcing is not right for everyone: two employees on stable hours with no award complexity may be fine with a good payroll system and a diary reminder. It earns its place when enough people, award variation or turnover mean the check gets postponed, which is where payroll services pay for themselves.

Want the payroll reconciliation done on a set cycle?

A graduate accountant can run your pay cycle, keep records complete and document the comparison.

Book a call back

Or call 1300 66 88 14, or try the savings calculator. No lock-in contracts.

Frequently asked questions

What is an enforceable undertaking?

An enforceable undertaking is a written agreement between the Fair Work Ombudsman and someone who has not followed a workplace law. The regulator uses one instead of going to court, generally where an investigation has found breaches and the employer is willing to fix them voluntarily and agree to preventative measures. It typically includes an acknowledgement, actions to remedy the breach, and future compliance commitments. All of them are published on the regulator’s website.

How often should payroll reconciliation be done?

There is no single legal interval for every employer. Awards that allow annualised wage arrangements usually require a review every 12 months, or sooner if the arrangement or the employment ends. The Fair Work Ombudsman also says employers should check when award rates or entitlements change and when an employee’s hours or classification change. Many businesses run a light check each pay cycle and a full reconciliation annually, after the annual wage review.

How long do payroll records have to be kept in Australia?

Time and wages records have to be kept for 7 years under the Fair Work Ombudsman’s record-keeping rules. They have to be readily accessible to a Fair Work Inspector and legible in English. They cannot be altered unless the change corrects an error, and they cannot be false or misleading. Pay slips are a separate requirement and have to be issued within 1 working day of pay day, electronically or in hard copy.

Does superannuation have to be paid on back pay?

Superannuation follows ordinary time earnings, so where back pay relates to ordinary time earnings the super guarantee generally applies to it as well. In the NAB matter the Fair Work Ombudsman reported more than $8 million in applicable superannuation alongside the wages and interest. The ATO sets the super guarantee rate at 12% of ordinary time earnings for payments made from 1 July 2025. Confirm your own position with your registered tax or BAS agent.

When do pay slips have to be given to employees?

Pay slips have to be given within 1 working day of pay day, even if the employee is on leave. They can be electronic or hard copy, and electronic pay slips must carry the same information as paper ones. The required content includes the employer and employee name, the employer’s ABN, the pay period, the date of payment, gross and net pay, loadings and allowances that can be separated out, deductions, and superannuation contributions.

What is the difference between payroll reconciliation and payroll outsourcing?

Payroll reconciliation is a task: comparing what was paid against what was owed for a given period. Payroll outsourcing is a delivery model: handing the payroll function, including that task, to an external team. You can reconcile in-house without outsourcing anything, and you can outsource payroll without the reconciliation being performed unless it is written into the scope. If the check matters to you, put it in the scope explicitly.

This article is general information about Australian bookkeeping and reporting obligations, current as at 17 November 2026. It is not tax, financial or legal advice. FreeMyCloud is not a registered tax agent and does not prepare or lodge tax returns. Rates, thresholds and dates change. Confirm your own position with your registered tax or BAS agent.


Julian Mahoney — Founder, Free My Cloud

Julian Mahoney

Founder, Free My Cloud

Julian is the founder of Free My Cloud, an Australian firm specialising in offshore bookkeeping and accounting services for small and medium businesses. With years of experience helping Australian businesses reduce overhead and improve financial visibility through outsourcing, Julian and his team connect business owners with skilled professionals in the Philippines.